Acts of Volition

Comments

Comments are locked. No additional comments may be posted.

Steven Garrity -

Sweet logo too.

<p><table border="0" width="100%"><tr><td align="center"><img src="images/gamecube.gif" border="0" alt="GameCube logo"></td></tr></table>

vince -

Gamecube, xbox or PS2? Seriously.

I plan on buying a gaming system in January (<I>first since my NES</I>) and I have yet to play any of the three systems. I’m probably going to rent all three systems before my purchase, but until then, this is how it breaks down for me:
<p>
<ul>
<b>xbox</b><br>
I’ve had nothing but problems with my microsoft keyboard, so I’ve never been to confident in their microsoft’s hardware. Why should I buy their gaming system? This <a href="http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=01/10/23/1428238&mode=thread" target="_blank">article</a> doesn’t help, and neither does <a href="http://www.hardocp.com/new_img_01/oct/msxbox.html" target="_blank">this</a> screenshot. It may be the <I>bleeding-edge</I> but I think I’ll pass.
<p>
<b>Gamecube</b><br>
Nintendo always focused on gaming more than graphics, which is exactly what I want. Usually I’d feel safe going with Nintendo, but I’m unsure about the new mini-CD format.

They use the smaller CD’s (<I>2.5 inches I think</I>), which are next to impossible to burn. They may cut down on pirating games, but I’m just not going to buy the system in the first place if I can’t steal anything for it. Granted, I can’t burn PS2 or Xbox games yet, but they’re more likely to be cracked before Nintendo’s.

Nintendo hasn’t any history with this format of game. Is the jump from cartridges to CD’s going to work? It’s only been out for a month.

Unlike the other two systems, I can’t play DVD’s. I’d probably never use it to play my DVD’s anyways, but I want the most bang for my buck. <a href="http://www.consolewire.com/news/item.asp?nid=2066" target="blank">They trust Japan</a> with the DVD format, why not us? Fuckers.
<p>
<b>PS2</b><br>
- The system has had a year to build up a healthy roster of games
- I can play my old PS2 games on it (<I>if I had any</I>)
- DVD and CD playback

It may be only a year old, but it seems to be the most versatile and proven system out there.
</ul>

So the only problem is that I haven’t played any of the systems yet. Can I get some advice? Opinions? Rude comments?

Anyone?

Charlie -

I have rented a gamecube twice now, the first time on purpose, the second time because all the Xbox's were gone. For the second rental I actually went to WalMart and bought a memory card for the gamecube because there are very few games made anymore of a genre that you can really enjoy without a memory card. This is why I am leaning in favor of the Xbox. I enjoyed the gamecube both times, its a remarkable machine in a small package. But with component prices so low I find it to be a simple cash grab to tell me that I need to pay an extra $30-$50 to be able to save my games on my new $300-$500 system. XBox put an 8GB hard drive in. I'm sure that memory card for the gamecube is no more than 8MB! Could Nintendo not have put at least 64MB of fairly non-volatile battery backed up memory in the box? What would that have cost them, $10 or maybe $12 per system when they buy it in bulk? Consider as well that one of the games I rented was John Madden Football 2002 which informed me that to use the Franchise feature (build a team from the ground up) it would need one entire 59 block memory card for itself. That means that the game technically costs $30 more on the Gamecube than it would on the Xbox because you have to buy a dedicated memory card to use the same features. All of this plus the lack of DVD means that the gamecube will only be a rental machine for me, where as I might buy an xbox.

Rob -

<img src="http://image.lik-sang.com/images/170/panasonic-gamecube.jpg" alt="two handles on this one!" align="right">Vince, read this:
<P><P>In Japan, there is a Panasonic GameCube and it is a DVD player / Gamecube hybrid. The only snag is it doesn't play the local DVDs for North-America yet.

vince -

<br><a href="http://www.consolewire.com/news/item.asp?nid=2066" target="_blank">Don't hold your breath</a>.
<p>
I'm feelin' pretty ripped off right about now.

Isaac -

As a proud owner of a gamecube i think its the best purchase. Granted, it has no harddrives, but one memory card has enough space for many games (I have four games, and well under half my memory card is actually used.)

As well, the cheaper price allowed me to get more games on my budget, and i can't complain about one of them - they are all a blast.

I guess the real reason i went with nintendo though, is that I was one of those kids who never had an NES and always wanted one.

The downfall of it is, as vince said, the media will be impossible to copy for quite a while. I wouldn't worry about the system's horsepower though - it might not be as brute as the xbox - but its a very powerful system.

So, as a biased gamecube owner, i say get it - mainly for the games (Mario Sunshine, the new Zelda are coming out next year), and right now there are some greats like Super Monkey Ball, and Super Smash Brothers, and of course Luigi's Mansion.

vince -

<br>
<a href="http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=01/12/17/028205" target="_blank">News</a>
<p>
Kids are getting too smart these days.

vince -

<br>
As usual, <a href="http://www.lik-sang.com/catalog/master.php?navbar=Opened+Q&inc=qmod.inc" target="_blank">technology changes whithin five minutes</a>.
<p><center>
<img src="http://members.home.net/vincentland/photo/nin.jpg" border="1">
<p></center>
Suckers.

Matthew -

If the gamecube played DVDs, I would buy one immeadiately. Instead I will save my pennies for a bit longer, and get a ps2.<P>

If the xbox were not the weight and price of compact car and played DVDs, I would think about buying one. Seriously, have you seen the controllers? They're the size of small hams.<P>
What I really want is a ps2 with gamecube controllers.

Matthew -

Microsoft denies having plans.